top of page

When AI Rebuilds Adobe: The price of creative freedom

Writer: Brooke LeBeau
Brooke LeBeau
Oct 23
5 min read

When I started designing, I learned on Adobe CS5 and, if you can believe it, a very old and very outdated legacy version of PageMaker.


I remember when Adobe introduced Creative Cloud, and my brain couldn't quite wrap around the concept. I'd already forked over $350 for CS6, which felt like a small fortune at the time. Now I was supposed to pay for the software every month? Forever?


By 2015, my increasingly incompatible copy of CS6 had run its course, and I reluctantly joined the cloud.


More than a decade later, subscriptions have become a pretty unavoidable part of creative work. And while the software has gotten substantially more powerful, so has the cost of maintaining a professional creative toolkit.


Apparently, one developer decided he'd had enough.



What Happened?


In early October 2026, software developer Brandon Thomas made headlines for releasing ArtCraft, a collection of seven free, open-source applications designed to recreate familiar Adobe software.


And here's the interesting part: he used AI to help build them.


Using Anthropic's Claude Opus 5.5, Thomas developed the applications in Rust, a programming language known for its performance and memory safety.

The lineup includes:

ArtCraft

Adobe counterpart

PhotoCraft

Photoshop

VectorCraft

Illustrator

FilmCraft

Premiere Pro

LightCraft

Lightroom

EffectCraft

After Effects

DesignCraft

InDesign

PrintCraft / PdfCraft

Acrobat Pro

These aren't just mockups of what an alternative might look like. They're downloadable applications with working features, familiar interfaces, and ambitions to support the file formats designers already use. A single experienced developer, working with AI coding tools, produced early versions of applications that represent decades of software engineering at Adobe.


It's pretty wild.


But there's a difference between recreating the appearance of Photoshop and recreating everything Photoshop can actually do.



The Pain Point


I understand the motivation.


Adobe's full creative suite is expensive. At the time of writing, Creative Cloud Pro's standard US price is $69.99 per month. That's roughly $840 a year for one subscription.


And Adobe is rarely the only software bill.


There's Figma. Canva. Website platforms. Project management software. AI tools. Client-specific platforms. The list goes on.


For a studio like Artfully, where integrated creative support means meeting clients where they are, software flexibility is part of the job.


We don't always get to choose the platform.


Sometimes a client works in Figma. Another uses Canva. Someone needs a presentation in PowerPoint. Another needs an Illustrator file that their printer can open and edit. The expectation is that we can work within the systems already established, which means learning and maintaining access to an increasingly broad collection of tools.


And those subscriptions add up.


For freelancers, independent designers and small studios, that's a real consideration. So the idea of a free, open-source creative suite that can handle professional work? I get the appeal.



Why Build Something That Already Exists?


Thomas's project challenges the assumption that sophisticated creative software needs to come from a large company, live behind a subscription, or operate within a proprietary ecosystem.


ArtCraft is intended to be free, open-source and available across Windows, macOS and Linux.


Thomas describes the applications as independent implementations rather than copies of Adobe's underlying code. There are still questions about how closely software can reproduce another company's interface without raising intellectual-property concerns, but the larger idea is compelling.


What happens when building software becomes dramatically more accessible?


We've spent years talking about how AI might change the work designers produce but this is something different. AI is now helping people build the tools designers use to produce that work and that has the potential to change the economics of creative software in a pretty significant way.



But Can It Actually Replace Adobe?


Not yet.


And I think that's an important distinction in a story that's understandably getting a lot of attention. On October 13, Creative Bloq published a hands-on review of PhotoCraft, LightCraft and FilmCraft. The results were promising in some areas and pretty rough in others. PhotoCraft could open and save Photoshop files and offered familiar layers, masks and adjustment tools. But automatic selections, healing tools and content-aware functions weren't nearly as precise as their Adobe counterparts. LightCraft had recognizable photo-editing controls, but issues with sharpening, masking and camera-specific color profiles. FilmCraft could handle basic video editing, but high-resolution footage, format compatibility and performance presented significant limitations.


These are early-stage applications, and the developer has acknowledged that they're not ready to replace established professional software.


Which is fair. They were just built!


But it highlights something I think gets lost when we talk about how quickly AI can generate software.


Building something that works is not the same as building something that works reliably, repeatedly and within a professional workflow.


That's where years of development, testing and refinement start to matter.



Who Could Benefit?


Even if ArtCraft isn't ready for professional production, I can see why people with limited budgets might be interested in it.


Folks like students learning the fundamentals, hobbyists experimenting, independent creators, or even people who simply don't need every advanced feature could really benefit from ArtCraft. I don't think every person who wants to edit a photograph or design a poster should have to invest hundreds of dollars in software to get started.


There are already capable free and lower-cost alternatives out there, and ArtCraft is entering that conversation at an interesting time. If continued development makes these applications stable and accessible, they could eventually become another useful option for professionals.


For now, I view them as an experiment worth watching and a great resource for people starting to dip their toes into design.



The Problem I Keep Coming Back To


File compatibility.


This is the part that makes me hesitate, and it's something I already deal with regularly.


A client might have an established workflow in Figma, but the final deliverable needs to be an editable Adobe file. And while there are ways to move work between platforms, the process isn't always seamless. Suddenly, the time saved working in one platform gets spent rebuilding the same design in another.


It's not necessarily a problem with either tool. It's a problem with how the tools communicate and when you're collaborating with marketing teams, printers, developers, agencies and other designers, compatibility isn't a minor convenience.


It's part of the deliverable.


That's where I think ArtCraft has its biggest challenge. A file that looks perfect on my screen but can't be reliably opened, edited, or produced by the next person in the workflow isn't worth as much to the client as the finished product.



So, Is This the Beginning of the End for Adobe?


Slow your roll.


Adobe has spent decades building software, infrastructure, compatibility standards and professional workflows that can't be recreated overnight. But I do think ArtCraft represents something worth keeping an eye on.


For years, the barrier to creating sophisticated software has been enormous. AI-assisted development is changing that and while the first generation of these applications may be imperfect, the speed at which they're being created is impressive.


More competition could mean better tools, more accessible pricing, and more options for creative professionals. 


Those are all good things!



Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
bottom of page