top of page

It's Alive! The making of a Frankenstein Brand

Writer: Brooke LeBeau
Brooke LeBeau
Oct 30
6 min read

A Monster Is Born


The laboratory is dark. A slow trickle of water echoes against the tile floor in the distance. Nothing else permeates the walls except the electric hum of a generator, patiently waiting to be turned on.


Dr. CEO's calculated smile stretches wide, his eyes twinkling with promise and potential.


Before him lies the monster.


Its left arm buzzes with the robotic whirring of the Chief Technology Officer. Its right arm, borrowed from a previous employer, comes courtesy of the Controller. Its torso is a patchwork of colors, lovingly stitched together by the Marketing Director. And its head? A practical, sensible shape bearing the same unwaveringly neutral expression as the COO.


You get where I'm going with this.


After months of meetings, revisions, competing opinions, and more than a few PowerPoint presentations, the switch is finally flipped.


IT'S ALIVE!


Unfortunately, nobody is quite sure what it is.


And that, my friends, is how a Frankenstein Brand is born: an identity assembled from an assortment of opinions, borrowed inspiration, and individually reasonable ideas without a clear North Star to guide them.


Maybe there were too many big personalities in the room. Maybe the organization lacked a unified vision. Maybe everyone was so focused on contributing something valuable that nobody stopped to consider whether those contributions belonged together.


Have you ever watched a commercial or scrolled past an ad and thought, “Wait... but what do they actually do?”


Sometimes that's what happens when too many cooks get into the kitchen. And they might all be Michelin-starred chefs. But that doesn't mean their ingredients belong in the same dish.



How to Build Your Very Own Frankenstein Brand


Step 1: Collect your body parts


First, gather the finest ingredients from the world's most recognizable brands.


  • Nike's swoosh.

  • Coca-Cola's iconic script.

  • McDonald's unmistakable red and yellow.


Individually? Iconic.


Together? An identity crisis waiting to happen.


Now imagine bringing the creative minds behind these brands into the same room. Someone says, "When I was at Coca-Cola, this script was the turning point that made us the bestselling soft drink on the planet."


That's a pretty compelling argument.


It's easy to hear something like that and think, Well, it worked for them. Let's do that. The trouble is, here isn't Coca-Cola. What made one brand successful was the result of its particular audience, history, positioning, strategy, and a thousand other decisions that worked together over time. You can't extract one successful ingredient, drop it into an entirely different organization, and expect the same result.


Inspiration is valuable. Experience is invaluable. But imitation without intention creates a brand without its own personality.



Step 2: Add a few extra limbs


Every stakeholder has a brilliant idea.


Someone wants another color. Someone else thinks the logo needs a tagline. Sales wants more messaging. Leadership wants a second font because the first one doesn't feel exciting enough.


And rather than making decisions, we accommodate everyone.


Before long, our monster has seven arms, three heads, and absolutely no idea how to walk. Here's the thing: those suggestions might actually be good but they just aren’t solutions to the problems we're trying to solve.


Imagine a Sales Director saying the brand needs to feel warmer and more approachable. Their proposed solution? Change the color palette. But what if the problem isn't visual at all? The real problem is that the sales script feels transactional and the customer experience lacks a personal touch.


Changing the brand colors won't solve those problems.


Good creative direction isn't just knowing which ideas to use, It's knowing where they belong. Collaboration should bring different perspectives into the process, but it shouldn't mean incorporating every suggestion into the final outcome. Design dean’t solve every problem just like an operational enhancement doesn’t fix a broken sales process.


Sometimes the best thing you can do for an idea is put it somewhere else.


And sometimes you have to leave it on the laboratory floor.


Step 3: Stitch everything together


Now it's time to make all those disconnected pieces look like they belong together. The website has one personality and social media has another. The sales deck looks like it belongs to a completely different company.


But don't worry! They all use approximately the same shade of blue.


Consistency is one of those branding concepts that sounds incredibly simple until you start looking at what it actually means. It's not just using the same logo, fonts, and colors. It's the way your sales team talks about the business and the tone of your customer service emails. It’s the user experience someone has navigating your website and the promises an organization makes.


A brand isn't simply what an organization looks like. It's the collection of experiences that teach people what to expect from it.


If those experiences contradict one another, even the most beautifully designed identity won't hold everything together.


A few matching colors can't hide a monster's mismatched personality.


Step 4: Give it a jolt of life


The launch date is approaching.


Strategy? We'll figure that out later.


Brand guidelines? Maybe next quarter.


Testing? There's no time.


Someone has already booked the launch party, the website needs to go live, and leadership is expecting results.


Just get it out the door.


The generator roars.


Lightning cracks across the sky.


IT'S ALIVE!


At first, everyone celebrates. The new website looks great and the launch announcement goes out with a shiny new logo on the office wall.


Then the numbers start coming in. Customers aren't responding the way everyone expected, the sales team struggles to explain the positioning, and marketing can't seem to make the messaging stick.


Suddenly, Dr. CEO wants to know who's responsible.


Maybe the campaign wasn't strong enough and the marketing team needs new leadership or maybe the sales department needs a new playbook. Sometimes organizations start changing people, processes, and tactics in an attempt to fix something that was never clearly defined in the first place.


That's an expensive way to discover your monster doesn't have a backbone.


When a brand lacks a clear foundation, the problems don't disappear at launch. They multiply. And the people responsible for bringing that brand to life are often left trying to make sense of a strategy that never really existed in the first place.



The Real Monster: Design by Committee


Here's the scary part.


Frankenstein Brands rarely happen because someone had a terrible idea. They happen because too many individually reasonable ideas were never evaluated against a shared vision.


And honestly, that's what makes these situations so tricky.


Everyone is trying to improve the work with the best of intentions. 


The CEO is thinking about the future of the business. Sales is thinking about customers. Marketing is thinking about engagement. Operations is thinking about practicality.


Those are all valuable perspectives but they're also different perspectives.


Without a clear strategy connecting them, every suggestion becomes another piece stitched onto the monster and this isn't an argument against collaboration. Quite the opposite. The best creative work benefits from people who understand different parts of the business. The challenge is knowing how to translate those perspectives into one cohesive direction.


That requires someone to listen, interpret, prioritize, and occasionally say no.


Collaboration should make a brand stronger, not turn it into a collection of compromises.



How to Keep Your Brand From Becoming a Monster


Fortunately, preventing a Frankenstein Brand doesn't require a lightning rod or an underground laboratory.


  1. Start with a backbone: Before choosing colors, fonts, or messaging, establish what the brand stands for, who it's speaking to, and what it's trying to accomplish. A clear strategy gives every decision something to connect to.

  2. Know when to put down the needle: Not every suggestion needs to become part of the final product. Sometimes an idea belongs in a different campaign, a different customer touchpoint, or nowhere at all. Editing is just as important as creating.

  3. Keep someone in the laboratory: Brands need ongoing creative stewardship, especially when multiple departments, vendors, and creative partners are contributing to the work. Someone needs to understand the whole picture and help keep the pieces working together.



Just Because You Can Doesn't Mean You Should


The problem with Frankenstein Brands isn't that they're made from different parts.


Every brand is.


Strategy, design, messaging, customer experience, marketing, sales, operations are all different pieces working together to create something bigger than themselves. The problem is when nobody stops to ask whether those pieces actually belong together.


So the next time someone suggests adding another font, another color, another tagline, or another brilliant idea to the mix, remember: Just because you can stitch it on doesn't mean you should.


Happy Halloween from the laboratory at Artfully.

Comments


bottom of page